CA1: Indonesian Christian not beaten by fiancé because of religion

Lumanauw v. Mukasey, No. 07-1307.  This reads, “In her petition for review, Lumanauw contends that the denial of her withholding application is erroneous because the administrative record compels a finding that it is more likely than not that she would be threatened by her ex-fiancé and the police on account of her Christian beliefs were she repatriated to Indonesia…. The record contains no conclusive evidence that petitioner’s ex-fiancé’s actions were motivated to any extent by petitioner’s Christian beliefs.”